A Democratic New York congressman has demanded that New York City Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch take action against federal immigration agents accused of violating state laws. Congressman Dan Goldman (NY-10) joined Comptroller Brad Lander and Public Advocate Jumaane Williams at a press conference urging the NYPD to enforce local laws and hold federal immigration officers accountable for alleged misconduct, including potential arrests of agents who “illegally assault or detain New York residents.”
Goldman’s call followed a letter to Tisch detailing multiple instances of federal immigration officers allegedly abusing their authority by detaining, arresting, and deporting American citizens and lawful non-violent New Yorkers. The congressman criticized the actions of “masked ICE agents,” stating, “The rule of law still governs New York City.” He argued that federal agents acting without legal authority could be subject to New York state laws, including arrest if they use excessive force.
Federal authorities have responded with criticism, with Department of Homeland Security spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin accusing Goldman of enabling “criminal illegal aliens” in the city. However, former ICE official Scott Shuchart supported the congressman’s stance, asserting that state law enforcement should intervene when agents break the law.
Legal experts, including former federal prosecutors, questioned the feasibility of NYPD policing federal agents, citing federal immunity protections. Goldman, a former federal prosecutor, acknowledged these challenges but maintained that officers acting outside their authority should not be shielded.
The debate comes as federal immigration agents intensify operations in cities like Chicago and Los Angeles, where confrontations have led to violence. In New York, enforcement has primarily targeted government buildings, though street raids are increasing. The DHS reiterated that its “enforcement operations are highly targeted” and do not involve U.S. citizen arrests.
